Mysterious Stories Blog

Strange, disturbing and mysterious stories from the outdoors

StrangeOutdoors 10/27/17 StrangeOutdoors 10/27/17

The tragic disappearance and deaths of Jo Elliott-Blakeslee and Amy Linkert in Idaho

Jo Elliott-Blakeslee and Amy Linkert disappearance

Jo Elliott-Blakeslee and Amy Linkert disappeared September 24, 2013 Craters of the Moon National Monument, Idaho. Bodies discovered September-October 2013.

Revised September 2024

Doctor Jodean “Jo” Kay Elliott-Blakeslee, 63, was a physician at the Snake River Correctional Institution in Ontario, Oregon, and Amelia “Amy” Linkert, 69, had retired from teaching at Lowell Scott Middle School in Meridian, Idaho.

The two women left Boise in Idaho on September 13, 2013, to visit the Craters of the Moon National Monument and Preserve. They never returned. The Monument has dangerous, jagged rocks and stormy weather hit the area during their trip. What happened to Jo and Amy in the famous Idaho destination in September 2013?

What is the Craters of the Moon National Monument and Preserve?

Craters of the Moon National Monument and Preserve, located in the Snake River Plain in central Idaho, was established on May 2, 1924. It is along US 20 (concurrent with US 93 and US 26), between the small towns of Arco and Carey, at an average elevation of 5,900 feet (1,800 m) above sea level. The protected area's features are volcanic and represent one of the best-preserved flood basalt areas in the continental United States.

A presidential proclamation by President Clinton in November 2000 greatly expanded the Monument area. In August 2002, the 410,000-acre National Park Service portions of the expanded Monument were designated as Craters of the Moon National Preserve.

The area has three major lava fields and about 400 square miles (1,000 km2) of sagebrush steppe grasslands, covering a total area of 1,117 square miles (2,893 km2).

The trip to Craters of the Moon National Monument

After leaving for the Craters of the Moon National Monument in Idaho, Jo and Amy failed to return from their visit as planned on Friday, September 20, 2013.

They were reported missing on Tuesday, September 24th. Employees who worked with Dr Jo called the police when she failed to show up at work. However, the federal government was shut down at the time due to a funding crisis and that meant that the search started nearly a week later on October 1st. Fortunately, ten park service rangers continued to look for Jo and Amy on foot without access to government resources, such as search helicopters, dogs or planes, in the days before the official search began.

They were spotted at a campground in Arco, about 18 miles away from Craters, on September 19. Police say they found receipts from the Craters of the Moon visitor's centre indicating they were at the monument on Tuesday, September 24.

Their vehicle was later found at the Tree Molds Trail parking lot, a popular trailhead in the monument. Strangely, the women's dogs, cell phones and other items were found inside their pickup truck at the trailhead. The fact that they left their two dogs behind suggested they didn't plan to be gone for long.

Jo and Amy’s family said they wouldn't go off trail or out of sight of the track because their dogs were in the car. Tammy Kerklow, Amy's niece, said, "They were both missionaries, they're both avid hikers, survivalists. This is very strange. To have their phones, I mean, I know they probably wouldn't work in the caves, but to leave them in the truck, that's strange to us."

Craters of the Moon National Monument and Preserve sign

The search and rescue team searched with that in mind. The search was concentrated in a five-square-mile area on the south end of the monument near the Tree Molds, Broken Top Loop, and Wilderness Trails. The search area was in rugged, often dangerous territory and prone to unpredictable weather. But they didn't find them despite the intense search effort, which saw 6,000 volunteer search hours.

Discovery of Amy Linkert’s remains

Search and rescue teams expanded the search area, and on September 25, 2013, in a lava field northwest of the Tree Molds Trail, they found Amy Linkert's body.

She was found face-up on the lava, wearing only a short-sleeve shirt and pants without a jacket, backpack, food or water. Rescuers believed she became disoriented while possibly searching for help and died of exposure. Authorities did not suspect foul play in her death. Initially, the searchers thought they had found Jo as there was no identification on the body, but dental records confirmed that the body was Amy’s.

search-and-rescue-workers-craters-of-the-moon

The Discovery of Jo Elliott-Blakeslee

After the search had gone on a whole extra month, searchers finally found Jo about a mile from the location of Amy’s body in October 2013. It was two and a half miles from the pickup in an area that had overflights from search helicopters for the past month in an area where the rock obscured the body.

Both women appeared to have died of exposure and showed signs of dehydration. How and why the women were separated remains unclear. But perhaps one of the two became injured, and the other woman sought help and got into trouble.

Questions about the disappearance and deaths of Jo Elliott-Blakeslee and Amy Linkert

Many questions remain about this case:

Why did Jo and Amy leave their dogs and mobile phones in the pickup, suggesting they planned to stay nearby? When the two women visited, a storm hit the area around the Monument. Were they panicked by the storm and became disoriented by the wild weather?
Why was Amy found face-up on the lava, wearing only a short-sleeve shirt and pants without a jacket, backpack, food, or water? Why did she go on the trail with no equipment or supplies? The visit was intended as a short hike, as the dogs were left in the vehicle. Was it as simple as the weather changing? Perhaps.
How and why were Jo and Amy separated? Did one get injured before the other by the jagged lava rocks in the area?
Why was Jo found so far from the trailhead car park, and why did it take over a month to see her body despite numerous flyovers by helicopters? - The easy explanation is that the rock in the area can easily obscure bodies

Although the authorities have dismissed foul play, it seems unlikely that the two just left their dogs behind and went wandering in this potentially dangerous terrain without supplies. What made them leave the pickup truck behind and then separate? As the family member said they were both keen hikers and survivalists, not naive and not inexperienced in these wilderness areas. A sad end to these ladies’ lives in the amazing scenery of the Craters of the Moon National Monument.

StrangeOutdoors Exclusive Members Only Area

$15.99

One time

Exclusive articles for members of StrangeOutdoors that are not available elsewhere on the site.

✓ 62 articles as of June 2024

See the latest Exclusive members-only articles on StrangeOutdoors.com

Read other strange stories from Idaho

The Strange disappearance of Connie Johnson from Big Fog Mountain

The shockingly weird disappearance of Terrence Woods

The unexplained disappearance of Susan Seymour Adams

The strange disappearance and death of Todd Hofflander in Hells Canyon

The controversial disappearance of DeOrr Kunz Jr